Monday, 27 October 2008

Update on the digital switch over

During the party conference I made a point to stop by the Digital UK exhibition stand. Accompanying the coming digital switchover are some concerns concerns, such as the implications for BBC Alba, as well as opportunities. I wanted to voice those concerns to a representative of Digital UK - the company working with the Scottish Government and local authorities through to community councils and local voluntary organisations to make sure the switchover message reaches every household.


Photo: Rob with Digital UK's robot mascot Digit Al.






Friday, 24 October 2008

Young and old alike get the bug

John O'Groat Journal
By Rob Gibson MSP
Published: 24 October, 2008


IN recess weeks, regional and party activity never ceases.


During these "tattie holidays" I have been at engagements in the Far North as well as in Falkirk, Fife and the Fair City of Perth thus far. With all eyes focused on the world financial turmoil, our SNP conference in Perth last week had to address these big issues. And it did so successfully. As if our round of speeches, fringe meetings and socialising were not enough, many activists, including myself, took the bus to Glenrothes to put in a couple of hours' campaigning in the important by-election due on November 6.

A bit of history was played out on that trip. It concerns the man who led the student raiders on Westminster Abbey at Christmas 1950. Ian Hamilton drove the Stone of Destiny back to Scotland from London nearly sixty years ago. Last Thursday, now an octogenarian, he drove four of us from the campaign HQ in Markinch a couple of miles to Coaltown of Balgonie for our canvassing stint. Then he returned to his task of stuffing envelopes.

Yes, there's a Caithness link – he bought his current car in Halkirk and had much pleasure in describing his journey there to make the purchase. Ian appears in a cameo role in the new film about his exploits called Stone of Destiny which is now on general release.

Make no mistake, young and old alike get the bug for Scottish freedom. This was underlined by Professor James Mitchell, of Strathclyde University, who gave the annual Donaldson Lecture at the SNP conference. His research shows that the SNP attracts far more young people into politics than all other parties put together. That was evident at various events from the Young Scottish Nationalist Karaoke to the Conference Review and Ceilidh as well as the conference debates.

We even attracted a cross-party performance from the House of Commons rock band MP4. (Get it?) Our own Pete Wishart MP, the former Runrig keyboard player, has two Labour MPs on lead guitar, bass guitar and vocals and a Tory on drums. The dance floor filled up with all ages. Maybe in another world it could have been Tony Blair on lead guitar.

*

SERIOUS politics in the conference hall was dominated by constructing a Scottish response to banking woes and the sudden end to an all-party truce over the crisis. It had been all too tempting for Gordon Brown to display the gut unionist argument against small nations. Iceland's bank troubles provided the pitch and he tried to score a winning goal against the SNP.

Not only does London Labour continue to rubbish Scotland's ability, were we independent at this time, to manage such a financial crisis, they have taken to besmirching the record of our neighbours Ireland, Iceland and Norway as well.

This is the same Gordon Brown who has lectured other European leaders for the past decade on the need for deregulation. Now his tune has had to change. As my colleague Dr Aileen McLeod highlighted in the Europe debate, a European-wide financial regulatory agreement is much needed. We have to learn from Norway and Sweden, who sorted out their own banking crises a decade ago. How did they do it, and how can Scotland escape from the jaws of the City of London, the most unregulated financial centre of all? The Prime Minister coined the phrase "stronger together, weaker apart". As with many issues, such as agriculture, green energy and environmental concerns, Scots have more friends in France, Ireland, Austria and Denmark than does London Labour. So the European elections next June are a straight choice between co-operation with our neighbours to create a confederal Europe of free partners or continued thralldom to boom-and-bust thanks to bankrupt London.

*

FUEL, food and heating costs are hitting most families. Wherever you live, be it Glenrothes or Caithness, we await Chancellor Darling's undoubted demand for higher taxes to pay for unprecedented Government borrowing. Mr Brown says we need to spend our way out of this crisis. But the cost will hit high streets after the failures in Threadneedle Street where the Bank of England has its HQ.

That's why I seconded the topical resolution at the SNP conference on climate change. It argued that we must press ahead with marine renewables to create jobs and clean power; also home insulation will reduce heating costs and can employ construction workers who are caught in the house-building slump. Meanwhile in Europe, the Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS), the continent's main means to curb the greenhouse-gas emissions of big industry, must not be watered down due to fears that big firms will take jobs elsewhere in this recession to avoid compulsory carbon-emission costs essential to the ETS.

The Scottish Government can use its limited powers to kick-start building affordable homes, helping create a shared equity scheme for first-time buyers – but we also look to Ed Miliband, London's Secretary of State for Energy and Climate Change, to fight for a full ETS in Europe. Interconnectedness is inescapable but a seat at the top table is essential for Scots to have our say in such vital matters.

FALKIRK welcomed the Royal National Mod, the annual Gaelic festival, with open arms last week. Meanwhile, the last-ditch bid by Caithness councillors to stop the entry of Gaelic road signs to the county sends mixed messages for Mod 2010. A genuine Caithness welcome would underscore the regenerative powers of culture and languages that accompany the surge of interest in tidal power potential. Well done, Dounreay, for backing the Mod – let's hope our councillors do too.

-Rob Gibson MSP

Tuesday, 14 October 2008

Congratulations to Julie Fowlis, Scotland's first Gaelic Ambassador

Press Release
12 October 2008:

Rob Gibson, SNP MSP for Highlands and Islands has congratulated Julie Fowlis on becoming Scotland's first Gaelic Ambassador.

In lodging a Scottish Parliamentary motion, he said,

"Julie Fowlis is among the best examples today of young musicians who have emerged from the Gaidhealtachd and trained in the Feisean movement. Julie has won many awards in her career so far. As Scotland's Gaelic Ambassador at the age of 29 I believe she is a positive upbeat role model. That's because she has determinedly stuck to performing in her own native tongue, North Uist Gaelic, and won the hearts of audiences in Scotland, England, America and the rest of Europe."

Rob, himself a seasoned singer and festival organiser continued,

"The importance of Julie's win comes at a time when Scotland is displaying a cultural vibrancy that can set a confident course for our unique linguistic inheritance as we approach the Year of Homecoming 2009. Even in troubled financial times we know as a nation how to sing."

"Well done Julie, you represent the very best of Scotland's outward-looking, traditionally-based musical culture which we invite all Scots and many others to enjoy."

Photo: Rob and Julie at Celtic Connections in Glasgow:




Draft motion submitted 11.10.08
The Parliament congratulates Julie Fowlis, traditional Gaelic singer and multi-instrumentalist, for gaining the accolade of first Gaelic Ambassador for Scotland; welcomes the Scottish Government's sponsorship of this new award announced at the National Mod in Falkirk; recalls that the First Minister, in opening the Mod itself, described Gaelic as a unique vehicle for passing Scottish understanding from one generation to the next; believes that the celebration of Gaelic raises the self-esteem of our national culture; and encourages all Scots to celebrate the contribution of Gaelic to our national fabric and praises the part Julie's warm personality and well-deserved public profile can play as a popular role model for all young singers and musicians.

Saturday, 11 October 2008

Bank speculation behind every boom and bust

Column in the John O'Groat Journal


“Most stop-go problems that Britain has suffered in the last fifty years have been led or influenced by the more highly cyclical and often more volatile nature of our housing market.” With these words Gordon Brown as Chancellor for ten years put his finger on the core problem of each trade cycle. The quote appears in a book written by Fred Harrison published in 2005 entitled Boom Bust, house prices, banking and the depression of 2010.

Unfortunately our Prime Minister failed to heed the facts that every boom and bust since the eighteenth century has rested on bank speculation in land and property which has scythed through the savings of ordinary working people on each and every occasion. He was joined this week in failing to identify the roots of the problem by analysts as far apart politically as Will Hutton in The Observer and Eamon Butler of the Adam Smith Institute in Monday’s Scotsman who took a view of the current crisis starting in the 1890s and 1977 respectively.

As deputy convener of the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee I and my colleagues are taking a series of soundings from banks and businesses as to the effects of the credit crunch and the liquidity crisis throughout the world.
The 18 year trade cycle has hit new highs in the widespread devastation across many countries that this present bust has triggered.

It has been noticeable that some commentators such as Alf Young in The Herald have quickly pounced on the problems of Ireland and Iceland. He dislikes the SNP emphasis on small northern European nations. We call them the Arc of Prosperity, he echoes Iain MacWhirter, also in The Herald who now says they are the Arc of Insolvency. However MacWhirter notes that Norway and Sweden, who the SNP would include in the Arc, are calm and weathering the storms having reformed their banks in previous crises.

What are we to make of the problems that rock financial institutions large and small, of nations large and small, too? Being large did not protect Lehman Brothers, failing to moderate the housing boom in Dublin did not protect the Irish economy and the Icelandic bank crash was caused by rash investments by Icelandic business in a wide range of consumer firms in Britain. Of course Ireland and Iceland are not clambering to return to rule by Britain and Denmark. We know that international rules will have to be developed to avoid the causes, not just the symptoms of this crisis in future.

All Holyrood committees will be picking elements of the Scottish government budget for next year and trying to suggest ways that the unprecedented world economic crash can be addressed by government-led investment here at home.

CHILD POVERTY indices have been published of late. Statistics that cover each Westminster constituency show that 44% of children in Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross live in low income families. It is dreadful indictment of UK policies that condemn so many to the benefits trail. Campaigners say that low income means where no-one is working more than 16 hours a week or the family is receiving the full amount of Working Tax Credit. They say this is not a direct measure of exactly how many children are in poverty, but is a good indicator of which areas have the highest child poverty levels.

The Far North is in the upper half of the UK constituency figures for child poverty. Whilst Dounreay has underpinned a third of the family incomes over several decades the poverty of many others has steadily got worse when oil jobs disappeared, fishing and public service cuts reduced demand for shops and services. Now the world banking crisis and its knock on effect of likely increases in unemployment and consequent defaults on mortgages and deeper personal debt is in all our minds. But we need a determined effort to get low income families into real jobs that are not as part time as the campaigners identify as measures of poverty today.

The Scottish Parliament with limited spending powers has one hand tied behind our backs. But we will have to try and identify projects that the Government can back to rebuild shattered confidence and give young lives some much needed hope.

POST OFFICES that have survived closures and cuts are once again at the mercy of the Department of Work and Pensions in London. The DWP is largely responsible for the mess in which the Post Office network finds itself due to their decision to pressurise people to get pensions and benefits paid into bank accounts, slashing 40% of sub post office business.

Post Office card accounts were only introduced after fierce pressure and have proved to be a huge success, despite the obstacles put in its way by the UK government. It would be the ultimate act of vandalism if the DWP now compounded its original disastrous decision by removing the Card Account contract from the Post Office.

At a time of economic difficulty this would be a horrendous attack on the High Streets of towns and villages across Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross and, indeed, the whole of Scotland.

So keeping Post Office branches going is just part of the job of getting our economy onto its feet after rounds of unwanted deregulation. We know that the wider economic crisis demands that all parties must work together to address this crisis and stabilise the economy.

Also the Chancellor must get ahead of events, act to protect people's savings and ensure proper liquidity in the banking system. Banks must also have the confidence to once again lend to each other and more importantly to individuals and businesses in the real economy. The Westminster Government has been on the back foot – reacting to events. The Scottish Government is seeking their help because we urgently need a more proactive approach with a comprehensive plan to bring stability back to the markets.

Thursday, 9 October 2008

Hosting Slow Food Scotland

I entertained Catherine Gazzoli and Trevor Lathan of UK Slow Food on their visit to the Scottish Parliament. The prospects for setting up Slow Food Scotland are encouraged by their informal meeting with Richard Lochhead, Minister for Rural Affairs and Environment. Slow Food welcomed the innovation of the Scottish National Food and Drink Policy which is setting the pace in these islands.





Tuesday, 7 October 2008

'Caithness will reap a tremendous harvest'

Article Published in the John O'Groat Journal
-By Iain Grant
Published: 01 October, 2008


FIRST Minister Alex Salmond has said nothing should be allowed to stand in the way of tapping the Pentland Firth's potential to become the energy powerhouse of Europe.

advertising
Speaking on Monday after the way was cleared for the first wave of full-sized demonstration tidal-powered generators in Scotland, Mr Salmond said the firth is at the epicentre of the country's green-energy drive.

He said the stretch of water off Caithness can generate "extraordinary, almost unimaginable" quantities of power.

He told delegates at a regeneration conference in Thurso that this can make the Far North to renewable energy what Saudi Arabia is to the oil industry.

Mr Salmond said that for a fully-fledged commercial operation to go ahead, a super-grid, serviced by a subsea cable, would be required.

This, he said, would be needed when the industry developed beyond the first phase, which is intended to produce more than 700 megawatts of energy.

This will include plans revealed on Monday by an offshoot of Scottish Power to go ahead with marine energy ventures in the firth, as well as in the Sound of Islay and off the North Antrim coast in Northern Ireland.

The firm's announcement came in the wake of the Crown Estate inviting interest for seabed leases for future wave and tidal energy devices.

Mr Salmond said: "This is a start but it's a big start.

"We're at the very beginning of this new frontier in tapping this huge new energy resource.

"This has been talked about for years but now its actually happening.

"It's not something for the next generation – it's something for the here and now."

He continued: "The potential of the Pentland Firth is quite staggering and the Crown Estate will play a crucial part in enabling developers to take the next step and turn tested, reliable technology into the next wave of generating stations, pumping out electricity for homes and business."

He said that as the technology advances, larger units would be installed and the power output would grow into the gigawatts.

The potential, he said, could comfortably exceed Scotland's electricity consumption, equating to the output of 20 conventional power stations.

"It's clear that this area is the epicentre of tidal resource and the opportunity it provides is extraordinary," he told delegates.

"The seas around Caithness are going to reap a tremendous harvest, to the benefit of us all.

"This is a hugely important day in terms of the dream of bringing marine energy in extraordinary, almost unimaginable quantities to reality in this part of Scotland – the Saudi Arabia of marine power."

Mr Salmond said that marine turbines are set to replace fast reactors as the driving energy force in the Far North.

He was clear that development would not be jeopardised by moves to create a new seabird nature reserve off Stroma.

Local community representatives and politicians have raised concerns that the fledgling industry could be killed off were the current seabird clifftop protection area extended two kilometres into the Inner Sound in the firth.

The Scottish Natural Heritage proposal is currently being considered by environment minister Mike Russell.

Mr Salmond said there is no way he would allow a conflict to arise.

"Government agencies have their statutory responsibilities and they have to be allowed to carry these out without interference," he explained. "But nothing is going to be allowed to stop or interrupt or destroy the potential Scotland has of harnessing the fantastic natural resources which exist in the firth.

"We cannot afford to strangle the gosling that may lay the golden egg."

Mr Salmond highlighted a headline in a recent article on marine energy in the US magazine Fortune, which read "Scotland rules the waves". He quipped: "One day I hope to see a Sunday Post headline that Caithness rules the waves."

"We're well ahead of the field in this area," he said.

"We're ahead of the world and we're determined to stay ahead in providing a fantastic new power source that can help save the planet.

"All of us – and certainly our environmental agencies – should be right behind this and working to ensure that there are no obstacles put in the way as this infant industry starts to develop."

Mr Salmond said it is vital that local companies get a big slice of the action in terms of manufacturing and servicing the seabed devices.

He also backed moves to seek to attract new energy-intensive industries to the area on the back of the developments earmarked for the firth.

Households and businesses bordering the subsea turbines should also benefit from cheaper energy bills, he claimed.

"We want to ensure that the area that produces the power gets the major benefits from the power," he explained. "The vast potential of the Pentland Firth will mean more investment, more jobs and more opportunities for Caithness."

Mr Salmond said his Government is continuing to press to get rid of the current surcharge on grid connection charges in the islands and outlying parts of the mainland.

The current regime, he said, needs to be radically overhauled given that it is the farthest flung parts of Scotland where the vast bulk of the new wave of renewable energy will be coming from.

In addition, he said a new subsea inter-connector or super-grid is essential before the larger-scale generating devices are installed in the firth.

He believed this should be linked up with the continent as well as to the national grid.

Highlands and Islands Enterprise has just commissioned consultants to look at options to secure this much-sought after new link.

The Crown Estate's control over the seabed had long been viewed as a deterrent to marine energy developments around the Scottish coast.

But this was removed on Monday when the agency set out details of leases it is to offer for wave and tidal energy projects.

In the first announcement of its kind, the agreements are geared to produce over 700 megawatts by 2020.

The deadline for applications is April next year with the first devices scheduled to be in the water by 2010.

The Crown Estate has made it clear that firms whose bids include clearly defined community benefits will be favoured.

Rob Hastings, of the Crown Estate, said: "Unlocking the potential in the Pentland Firth is crucial to meeting Scottish Government renewable energy targets, stimulating the north of Scotland economy and boosting the fledgling renewables industry.

"The Crown Estate is keen to play a central role in generating confidence among investors and the process we are announcing is an important step towards achieving just that.

"As well as the economic opportunities, the area could become a world-class centre of excellence in wave and tidal power development, research, testing and environmental monitoring."

Scottish Power, meanwhile, announced it intends to go ahead with between five and 20 tidal turbines in the firth and the same number in the other two sites.

It has invested £1 million to set up a new company, Hammerfest Strom AS, in a joint venture with two Norwegian energy companies to spearhead what would be the world's largest tidal stream venture.

The sites in the firth, off Islay and North Antrim will deploy Norwegian-designed tidal turbines, assuming final tests prove positive.

The two-bladed, 30-metre tall devices, which have been likened to underwater wind turbines, are connected to an electrical generator mounted on a steel tower which is fixed to the seabed.

The three sites have the potential to generate a total of 60 megawatts – enough green energy for over 40,000 homes The company, which expects to have planning applications lodged by next summer with the devices scheduled to be installed by 2011, is considering basing its manufacturing in the Far North.

Keith Anderson, director of ScottishPower Renewables, said: “This is a historic day for the development of marine energy.

“The rapid technological advancement of tidal power has enabled us to progress plans for this substantial project which has the real potential to deliver significant environmental and economic benefits.”

Mr Anderson said a lead Scotland once had in wind power was not capitalised upon, with Denmark and Germany taking the initiative in developing the technology.

He said: “Tidal power provides Scotland with another chance to become the global leader in a new renewable energy industry.”

Monday’s announcement by the Crown Estate was welcomed by Dutch company Tocardo, which was the first to firm up plans for a marine energy development in the firth.

Managing director Hans van Breugel, who attended the conference along with operations director Pieter de Haas, said it is now seeking to secure a lease to allow it to go ahead with a 10 megawatt prototype plant.

“We have leased land at Wick harbour where we are to build the plant and we have secured a grid connection,” he explained. “The missing part in the jigsaw had been the Crown Estate lease and we’re very pleased with this announcement today as we can move forward fairly quickly.

“We’d be looking to have a device in the water by early 2010.”

Looking to the future, Mr van Breugel warned that a full-scale commercial operation will not happen without a new subsea power cable.

“That is the only way we as an industry will invest in the long term,” he said. “Everyone agrees the firth is an unrivalled site for marine energy but if there’s no grid connection, you’re not going to get the jobs and benefits that will come from major developments.

“That is a major obstacle which needs to be addressed and solved in the next five to six years, then there is a fantastic future here.”

Mr van Breugel anticipated his company’s Wick operation growing to employ 50 to 60 in four years’ time.

But he warned: “For us to make a final investment decision, we must be confident that this grid connection will take place.”

*

Far North MSP Jamie Stone yesterday called for the supply of cheap electricity to local households and businesses on the back of marine energy ventures in the Pentland Firth.

He said: “I believe that business parks should be established in the land areas adjacent to where the energy is produced. They should be supplied with cheap electricity below the national price.

“The effect of this would be that many businesses would consider relocating to the Far North. In addition, there could be opportunities here for local households.”

The Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross Lib Dem MSP intends to raise the issue during First Minister’s question time tomorrow.

Highlands and Islands SNP MSP Rob Gibson said that the commitment shown by the SNP Government to renewable energy will pay great dividends to the economies of Caithness, Orkney and north Sutherland.

Commenting on the news that ScottishPower Renewables has identified the Pentland Firth as one of its sites for commercial tidal farms, and that the Crown Estate has decide to open the Pentland Firth seabed for commercial marine energy projects, Mr Gibson said: “This is extremely welcome news for Caithness, Orkney and beyond.

“The First Minister’s announcement marks the start of a new period in marine renewable development and it is clear that the Pentland Firth as well as the areas bordering it will the centre of that development.”

“The conference was a success and shows that the wide community of Caithness is focusing in on moving towards a new future.

“The organisers deserve huge credit for their work.”

“The enormous opportunities that the Pentland Firth offers mean increased investment, more jobs and new opportunities. I find that prospect exciting.”

Saturday, 4 October 2008

Diary in the Ross-Shire Journal

The huge fall-out from the credit crunch has dominated First Minister’s Questions for three weeks on the proposed merger of HBOS with Lloyds TSB. Obviously the two banks have branches here in Dingwall, for how long? Our EET committee questioned representatives of the financial services and house builders. Meanwhile various solutions to save HBOS jobs and indeed the very substance of our oldest Scottish bank fill the airwaves.

Poignantly I picked out a copy of the Bank of Scotland’s history in the new Dingwall library at the Academy. It celebrated three hundred years of service since 1695. The copy was inscribed by the members of staff in the Dingwall branch. How much longer will they serve us as a proud and independent high street bank?

Alex Salmond’s call for greater regulation of financial transactions is welcome. I note that these disappeared almost entirely during the reign of Gordon Brown as Chancellor and PM. I also note that the eighteen year trade cycle has once again brought misery to many without Brown or the USA addressing the issue. Yet many of our neighbours such as France and Germany have much tighter banking regulation and have no such huge crisis in their economies.

SCOTTISH Parliamentary business is brisk. I sit on two committees with overlapping remits that involves extra seminars on energy and climate change. We are pursuing a detailed energy enquiry and preparing for the Climate Change bill expected in December.

That’s the staple diet of committee work. Also a hectic series of chamber debates affect us in Ross-shire. I spoke on the Government Future Programme on our first day back citing the importance of the North in contributing to our clean energy targets. The following week it was our Ferry Enquiry. We scrutinised Less Favoured Areas to seek a way forward for our livestock sector and vibrant communities in tough financial times. The next day I had to sum up for the Economy, Energy and Tourism [EET] committee as to whether we can grow our tourism income by 50% in the next seven years. All go!


A FORTNIGHT ago I attended a Highland Health Summit in Inverness Townhouse. Ideas for our public health were debated. MSPs, NHS, the police, prisons and Highland Council officers pitched in. Staff credit unions were suggested, credit crunch well in mind. Other suggested that volunteering even for an hour a month would be health promoting. A strong lobby sought the targeting of families with lower health prospects who often came to the attention of schools, doctors, social work, the courts etc.

My suggestion was that everyone should be given the opportunity to grow some of their own food. We heard that prisoners take pride in the cabbages they grow in Porterfield. Medics were intrigued at the idea of families having a few square metres of deep beds or allotments. Then I was delighted to read in The Herald Magazine that Monty Don is back to health. The former presenter of BBC Gardener’s World believes that the Scottish Government first national food and drink plan is in stark contrast to the UK Government’s lack of concern for home production. He envisages a national network of local communities sharing seed, knowledge, time and elbow grease, and believes he has enough of the common touch to persuade people to do it.

When you drive north on the A9 from Alness neat rows of huts and plots at Milnafua are seen. Demand grows in Inverness. We heard that Highland Council agreed in August to promote allotments so local food is on the menu with every year that passes.

rob.gibson.msp@scottish.parliamrent.uk

Thursday, 2 October 2008

Far North is key to Scottish economy take off



Photo: Rob and Danny Miller display Mey Selections produce.

CONFERENCE season for political parties can be inspiring, or fretful. Following the gaffes of Lib Dem UK leader Nick Clegg where he promised tax cuts, MSPs asked last week in the Less Favoured Areas debate why Lib Dems wanted more spending on their favourite causes.

From what part of their planned £800 million cuts in the Scottish budget would they come? Can we expect Wick High School to be replaced? Can we really get fair fuel prices while London holds tight on the purse strings?

Meanwhile New Labour in Manchester this week reminds us of a tale of two governments. London Labour is on the way out while the SNP Government is getting on with the job of governing. Newly-elected Scottish Labour leader Iain Gray spoke of being born in the NHS, meanwhile Nicola Sturgeon was restoring fairness to the NHS with the launch of a legally enforceable 12-week waiting time for surgery, Scotland's police were recording record drug seizures and Scotland's First Minister Alex Salmond was continuing his fight to keep Bank of Scotland jobs in Scotland.

Iain Gray attracted a very poor turnout for his conference speech as he faced another electoral disaster for his party and for himself. That's what a huge UK-wide analysis of real elections shows – that he would lose his own seat at the next Scottish Parliament elections.

In recent real elections such as in Glasgow last Thursday, the SNP won with a seven per cent swing from Labour. And with another election coming up in Glenrothes, voters know the SNP is on their side over rising fuel and energy bills whilst a distant Labour party is out of touch. In contrast the SNP conference scheduled for Perth from 16 to 19 October will be well-attended and upbeat.

NEVERTHELESS the mood music behind today's politics is scored by a precarious economy. It is a sobering reminder that Gordon Brown's 10-year stint as chancellor charted no end to boom and bust as he promised. Indeed the 18-year trade cycle hit its last big bust in 1992. That was part of the substance of my questions to panels of bankers and house builders in the economy, energy and tourism committee.

The credit crunch was our subject, the local threats to banks in Thurso, Wick, Kirkwall and Tain where there are both HBOS and Lloyds TSB branches, was very much in mind. What has to be explained is the increasingly lax regulation of our financial system during the Gordon Brown years. Also the outrageous nationalisation of key firms such as AIG in the USA and Northern Rock in the UK merely keep the current flawed system limping on. But investors and shareholders in previously sound companies are big losers along with every family that seeks a bank loan or mortgage. As for bank employees, First Minister Alex Salmond is trying to save the Bank of Scotland's jobs and repute through a cross-party banking summit.

It remains to be seen how we maintain access to development funds for the likes of tidal power, for rebuilding schools and all other public sector-led projects. That's why the Scottish Future's Trust set up by the SNP Government is crucial. Local moves could also try prudent borrowing for repair projects such as the Wick High School swimming pool, and the setting-up of credit unions in each part of the country. The issue of credit able to be repaid is at the roots of our economic revival. I note with interest that the value of farm and estate land hasn't been affected by the global uncertainties.

We are told that borrowers on the strength of a piece of land have to put up a third of the value in cash before having loans approved. That clearly has not happened in the housing market. Also MSPs noted that the French and German economies are not as deeply affected as that of the UK. So the market in housing has to be transformed if we are to avoid another credit crunch.

Debating the problems facing Less Favoured Areas, such as Caithness and Orkney, MSPs agreed that the wise words of the report on our hills and islands produced by the Royal Society of Edinburgh quite correctly recognised that vibrant communities are the key to life in any part of the country.

AS we have just celebrated Scottish Food Fortnight I am deeply impressed that growing much more of our own food and seeing it on supermarket shelves is a top priority. My recent visit to Mey Selections is evidence that good food, local markets, wider supermarket sales and supporting local hotels with top grade produce all go hand in hand.

Here in Caithness we have a model that is the envy of others. Doing what we do best such as producing fine cattle and sheep for market must be supported. Also this week I was delighted to read that Monty Don, the recent presenter of the BBC's Gardener's World agrees. He backs the SNP Government and its national food policy which aims to feed the nation better from our resources.

But we can do much more, I do hope that the Caithness Regeneration Conference next week will see a burst of renewed confidence for the county.

Certainly the plans for tidal power schemes are developing, the much expanded Caithness Chamber of Commerce should be able to take an industry lead to expand our energy potential using the multi-layered skills of the Far North work force. When Alex Salmond addresses the delegates there should be no doubt left in anyone's mind, Caithness, north Sutherland and Orkney are key bases for take-off in the Scottish economy.





Photo: Rob conducted the transport workshop with thirty participants in a mind mapping exercise at the Caithness regeneration Conference in Thurso on 29th September

Monday, 22 September 2008

Promoting the very best of Scotland

Published: 12 September, 2008
John O'Groat Journal and Caithness Courier



BEFORE I joined the colourful, musical protesters from traditional music groups outside Parliament a week ago, I questioned the culture minister Linda Fabiani if monetary support for the traditional arts from the Scottish Arts Council ought to be provided on the basis of their ability to promote the vitality of our living traditions?

Given the omission of the traditional arts from the previous administration's national companies programme, is it time to investigate whether a national company or agency should be set up to progress those arts?

She replied that the Scottish Arts Council is having discussions with those who were not successful in that flexible two-year funding round. The Government wants to promote the very best of Scotland and the uniqueness of its traditional culture, though the national company model might not be appropriate or celebrate the diversity and the wonderful traditions of our culture. However the Government's responsibility is to protect our traditional cultures and we are very willing to have that discussion.

My local SNP branch has submitted a motion for debate at the SNP annual conference to resolve the means to set up sustainable support for our unique culture.

**************************************************

'HAVE you been to the new Tesco, their steaks are better than the Asda ones?" two young female commuters were heard to say on the northbound train from Edinburgh last Thursday evening. Welcome to Scottish Food fortnight.

Last weekend Dr Rajendra Pachauri, chair of the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), suggests that one meat-free day a week would significantly reduce CO2 emissions. Then eating even less meat would go much further. Welcome to Scottish Food fortnight.

In response, renowned Scots food expert Joanna Blythman is quoted in the Observer as saying, "universal prescriptions for solving the world's food crisis should be treated with suspicion." As to "wet, green Britain, it lends itself to livestock production". Welcome, indeed, to Scottish Food fortnight!

Recognising that cattle and sheep production are key to areas like the Far North of Scotland, we take pride in the achievements of Mey Selections. No doubt they count as part of the eight per cent increase in demand for home-grown Scottish food. And I worry that siren voices in commercial farming are unprepared for the changes that are really necessary in production methods to tackle climate change.

Importing soya protein from Brazil cannot continue. Habitat destruction in the Amazon rain forests is a direct result. Furthermore, our concerns for lax animal welfare standards in South America have led to bans on Argentine beef imports. But much of it is grass-fed. Are our farms and crofts fully geared to grass-fed livestock? Do we produce enough winter feed in Scotland? Could we follow the Scottish Agricultural College pilot and grow more animal protein such as peas and beans?

During Scottish Food Fortnight, families may be tucking into tasty, locally-produced food. For most of us it's just as big a treat. For if we follow the example of the young women I mentioned on the north train, the only criteria will be price. Taste, origin, production methods and proper payment to the producer must go hand-in-hand in a serious Scottish Food Strategy. In heeding the IPCC advice we could eat one meat course less per week, but let's buy the local, tasty option that the supermarkets refuse to stock in quantity. Then we could afford a treat and reward some hard-pressed producers in our own back yard.


*********************************************

LAST week in Parliament, Forestry Commission Scotland held a reception for "Woods in and around towns" (WIAT). One example, at Easterhouse in Glasgow's east end, has been cleaned up. Gone are the junkies' needles, only pine needles and broadleaves now. And people do enjoy woods and respect them when given ownership and management. Such remarkable stories are repeated around Scotland.

When will Newtonhill woodland near Wick become a pleasure ground again? My recent inquiries with the Forestry Commission suggest that finding a safe, convenient solution will be agreed.

The gates of the community woodland were padlocked in March by the Highland Council after the discovery of poisonous substances resulting from the old refuse dump there. As the John O'Groat Journal reported, Friends of Newtonhill group sprang into action to pursue the development of alternative land following news the contaminated site might never reopen. Securing adjacent farm land to replant a new wood has been considered by the Forestry Commission. I believe they will.

Meanwhile work at Dunnet and Rumster forests, Guidebest and Achvarasdal, not to mention Borgie, show various forms of woodland management and replanting. Spurred by successive Scottish governments we are making forests human-friendly for horse riders, dog walkers, mountain bikers, joggers and those just seeking a quiet stroll. Even in tree-starved Caithness there are pockets of woodland that our neighbours in central Scotland would visit. More power to the volunteers who reclaim and maintain the woods and to Forestry Commission Scotland for embracing so enthusiastically the recreation role of our forests.

****************************************************

THE Scottish Government's programme for this session was debated in Holyrood. My contribution welcomed the freeze in council tax and the plans to bring in a fair, local income tax which is attracting Lib Dem support, so there is hope that unionist Labour and Tories can once again be dismayed by radical changes for the better emanating from Holyrood.

The bulk of my speech welcomed the forthcoming Climate Change and Marine bills. Pentland tidal power can counter CO2 big time by powering far more homes and businesses than using electricity in Scotland alone. Such a prize for the Far North is well recognised.

But I linked both bills in my contribution for fears are being voiced about SNH's plans to extend the Special Protection Area into the Pentland Firth. I believe the Marine Bill will balance out conflicting uses.

The Lib Dem closing speech by Ross Finnie acknowledged my hopes. He reminded us that marine spatial planning will be defined therein. I am glad that the promise of tidal power is propelling a demand for balanced planning of our seas.

Rob.Gibson.msp@scottish.parliament.uk

Monday, 15 September 2008

Plea not to ignore the Highlands

Telecom companies told: Don’t leave us behind

By Sue Restan
Published: 15/09/2008

Politicians are calling for telecommunications companies to include the Highlands when rolling out new technology in the UK.

Maxine Smith, who is one of the councillors for Cromarty Firth ward, said they seemed to ignore rural areas.

She said the latest 3G mobile broadband service was not yet available in most of the Highlands.

It is the third generation of mobile phone standards and technology, enabling network operators to offer users a wider range of more advanced services while getting greater network capacity.

Services include wide-area wireless voice telephony, video calls, and broadband wireless data, all in a mobile environment.

“It is important that we do not accept being left behind with technology or being left out of companies' programmes when new concepts are thought of and introduced in other places in the UK,” said Councillor Smith.

“The Highlands is as important as any other area in Scotland, England or Wales and should be equal in terms of infrastructure and tech- nology.”

The SNP councillor added: “Now this issue has been brought to my attention, I will be lobbying different quarters until the Highlands is brought on to a level playing field.”

Highlands and Islands SNP MSP Rob Gibson said he was about to do a consultation with people in various parts of the country about broadband rollout.

He is also keen to identify the places without 3G coverage.

Mr Gibson said: “My view is that the telecommunications companies could get a lot more business, from both Highland residents and visitors, if we had 3G.”


A spokesman for Vodafone said 3G was available only in a small area around Inverness and an even smaller area in Elgin.

He said there were no plans to increase coverage in the next six months.

“The rollout is always going to be a business decision and coverage is focused on the major conurbations. As was the case with 2G, it is an evolving pattern of coverage,” said the spokesman.

An Orange spokeswoman said:

“We already offer 3G coverage in high population areas in the Highlands. We will continue to invest to enhance the experience for our customers.”

Thursday, 11 September 2008

Gibson welcomes marine milestone

News release

11/09/08

Highlands and Islands SNP MSP Rob Gibson has hailed the news that OpenHydro has successfully mounted a tidal turbine on the sea bed of the Pentland Firth.

The device was lowered onto the sea bed by a unique barge which was developed by OpenHydro for the purpose and is the only one of it's kind in the world (whose home port is Kirkwall).

Commenting on the news Mr Gibson said...

"This is a monumental moment in the development of the Pentland firth and will go down as a milestone in the furtherance of green energy both in Scotland, Europe and the world."

"Great credit has to go to the European Marine Energy Research Centre and OpenHydro for their sterling work which has led to this situation. It shows what can be achieved through co-operation and a common purpose."


ENDS

Gibson hails 'Fishing for Litter' initiative

FOR IMMEDIATE USE: 11TH SEPTEMBER 2008

ATTENTION: NEWS DESKS

GIBSON HAILS ‘FISHING FOR LITTER’ INITIATIVE

Highlands and Islands SNP MSP Rob Gibson has hailed the ‘Fishing for Litter’ initiative coordinated by KIMO International, a pan Local Authority International Environmental Association, by lodging a congratulatory motion in the Scottish Parliament today.

The initiative has encouraged 54 fishing boats from the UK, Denmark, the Netherlands and Sweden to voluntarily collect over 400 tonnes of litter from the North Sea already. Over the next three years the initiative aims to encourage 100 boats to collect another 500 tonnes of marine litter from the waters around Scotland.

Commenting, Mr Gibson said...

"This is an excellent example of the kind of attitude everyone should take toward preserving our environment. I was only too happy to commend KIMO international and all the fishermen involved with the project in my motion to the Parliament. "

"Litter in the North Sea is not only environmentally damaging but also costs thousands per year in lost time, damage to nets, fouled propellers and contaminated catches. The Save the North Sea project demonstrated that, on average, each tonne of marine litter that accumulates in fisherman’s nets costs £1,300 in lost time alone. This goes to show that voluntary work such as this does pay off in the end."

Jimmy Buchan, skipper of the Amity II and one of the stars of the TV's "Trawlermen" series, has been participating in the initiative for several years and commented on Rob's motion saying:

"It's a great programme and from a fisherman's perspective I can tell you that it's working. Each year I go out I'm catching less and less litter and it's because of what we as fisherman are doing. We're going about our day to day jobs but also picking up this litter and disposing of it in a responsible manner and that is having a noticeable positive effect."

ENDS

NOTE:

Copy of motion to the Scottish Parliament:

Short Title: Fishing for Litter
S3M-02531 Rob Gibson (Highlands and Islands) (SNP): That the Parliament congratulates KIMO International and all the fisherman involved in the Fishing for Litter initiative; commends their work in reducing North Sea marine littering by bringing ashore litter gathered in their nets while fishing; applauds the goal of the initiative to encourage 100 boats to take part with the aim of collecting 500 tonnes of marine litter from the waters around Scotland over the next three years; notes that 400 tonnes of litter have already been collected by the 54 boats involved in the imitative, which is run in the United Kingdom, Denmark, the Netherlands and Sweden, and finally notes its benefit for all those using the North Sea and UK beaches as well as the positive financial impact on the UK fishing industry due to a reduction in the amount of marine litter.

Link to KIMO International's Save the North Sea Project comprising the initiative:
http://www.kimointernational.org/Projects.aspx






S3M-02531 Rob Gibson (Highlands and Islands) (Scottish National Party) Fishing for Litter

Short Title: Fishing for Litter S3M-02531 Rob Gibson (Highlands and Islands) (SNP): That the Parliament congratulates KIMO International and all the fisherman involved in the Fishing for Litter initiative; commends their work in reducing North Sea marine littering by bringing ashore litter gathered in their nets while fishing; applauds the goal of the initiative to encourage 100 boats to take part with the aim of collecting 500 tonnes of marine litter from the waters around Scotland over the next three years; notes that 400 tonnes of litter have already been collected by the 54 boats involved in the imitative, which is run in the United Kingdom, Denmark, the Netherlands and Sweden, and finally notes its benefit for all those using the North Sea and UK beaches as well as the positive financial impact on the UK fishing industry due to a reduction in the amount of marine litter.

Wednesday, 10 September 2008

Gibson calls for wider screening of BBC Alba

News release
Immediate release

10/09/08

Highlands and Islands SNP MSP Rob Gibson is calling on the UK Government and BBC to allow the BBC's new Gaelic channel to be available to terrestrial viewers via freeview as soon as possible.

BBC Alba, which launches next week, will only be available to satellite viewers. It is not due to be put on freeview until the digital switch over (due for 2010) and that will be subject to a review from the BBC Trust.

Mr Gibson said..

"I very much welcome the launch of the Gaelic service. I wish all those involved with it the best of luck and am sure it will go onto be a success. The potential to promote the language and culture through a dedicated channel is genuinely exciting and the possibilities are vast."

"However the rather large fly in the ointment is that for around a year and a half it will only be available through satellite. Given the public money being spent on the channel and the fact that it is under the banner of BBC it strikes me as ridiculous that it will only be available to those that have private satellite rental. The fact that the appearance on freeview is subject to a review by the BBC Trust is a worry. If they do not give the go ahead then it could really stymie the development and impact that the channel could have."

"I am not entirely sure how and why this situation came about, but in the light of the Broadcasting Commission For Scotland's report which seeks more access to Scottish output for Scottish viewers, I hope that a speedy and sensible decision can be reached and that we see BBC Alba on freeview before 2010."


ENDS

Note:

Copy of Motion Rob lodged in parliament

S3M-02511 Rob Gibson (Highlands and Islands) (Scottish National Party): BBC Alba - Speed Up Freeview Option— That the Parliament welcomes the launch of the BBC Alba Gaelic television channel; wishes that all those involved will make the service a success; notes the potential that it has to boost the profile of the Gaelic language while informing and entertaining people throughout the country; however also notes, with disappointment, the fact that this service is not intended to be available through Freeview until after the digital switchover and that this will be subject to a review by the BBC Trust, and calls on the UK Government and BBC to speed up this process so that the channel has the chance to be watched by Gaels and non-Gaels throughout the nation who possess a Freeview box but do not have cable nor a satellite television.

Tuesday, 9 September 2008

Farmer GM

FARMER GM

Alex Johnstone MSP in The Farmer [August issue] labels critics of GM technology Luddites who stand in the way of progress and lampoons the SNP Government as ‘puritans and technophobes’ for sticking with the precautionary principle. He unaccountably ignores that this is also the policy of many of our European neighbours. Of course for Alex, London knows best, that’s where Gordon Brown’s free trade views would stop any support for home agriculture in favour of cheaper, lower quality and potentially GM food imports. In short Alex ignores the widespread evidence that GM is not the silver bullet to dispel fears among Scottish farmers that they could incur an ‘unnecessary competitive disadvantage’ unless they embrace ‘cost saving’ GM technology.

Recently the NFUS turned up the decibels for GM as fuel, pesticide and fertiliser prices have sky rocketed. This may be drowning out reasoned debate when reducing producer costs is Jim McLaren’s main goal. It is noteworthy that he also displays apparent altruism with his claim that GM can feed the hungry world. But of course the inflated price of imported soya for animal feed is the main trigger for concerns among Scots livestock producers. Simultaneously pro-GM researchers offer genetic modification of blight resistant tatties. Could this be the tipping point for agribusiness to break the loose consensus on the precautionary principle that the Scottish Parliament has adopted broadly since devolution?

Hard evidence is widely available that GM technology is expensive, destructive to the environment and leads to dependency on huge seed and chemical corporations. Let’s turn to the agricultural equivalent of the International Panel on Climate Change (IPPC) whose former director is now director of the International Assessment of Agricultural Science and Technology for Development (IAASTD). This body, initiated by the World Bank, was formed by UN co-sponsors FAO, GEF, UNDP, WHO and UNESCO. Nowadays even Tories in Scotland accept the facts of global warming so why don’t Alex Johnstone and his friends accept the findings of the IPPC’s agricultural equivalent?

The IAASTD has concluded that data on a range of genetically modified crops shows highly variable yields, greater in some places and less in others. It doesn’t rule out safe GM crop development in future but rightly concludes that if the multi-million pound investment by corporations in transgenic research and development had been applied to improving conventional methods of local food production and distribution then the current world food crisis would have been more successfully addressed.

The overwhelming conclusion of IAASTD is that small-scale farming and ecological methods provide the way forward to avert the current world food crisis. That’s why my Parliamentary motion lodged in June welcomes the UK Government’s approval of the IAASTD reports without reservation as confirmed in a written Commons statement by Douglas Alexander MP.
I believe that 400 world scientists in the IAASTD are a formidable peer group to assess agricultural knowledge, science and technology. So I concluded my recent motion by encouraging the Scottish and UK governments to mainstream the thrust of the IAASTD report in agricultural policy development.


In the meantime Charles, Duke of Rothesay has been accused of an ignorant rant against GM crops which he dubbed ‘the biggest environmental disaster of all time’. As pro-GM scientists lined up to slate the Prince the raw nerve of the multinational biotech industries and their cheerleaders was exposed. In fact after 25 years of its development 2.4% of global agricultural land is under GM crops. Despite billions spent on GM research and development, GM crops have not improved yields. Even in the USA, the only partner in IAASTD to demur from its conclusions had two thirds of its agricultural land growing non-GM crops in 2007.

The crunch issue for Scottish producers and consumers is to heed the science, not ignore it. That suggests to me that the Scottish Crop Research Institute should be at the cutting edge of the reorientation of agricultural science and technology towards agro-ecological sciences, more organic, smaller scale and focused on producing good food locally, as advocated by IAASTD.

Here are a few practical suggestions. First, test the GM-free blight resistant Hungarian tattie, Sarpo Miras. Also evaluate and collaborate with Welsh and Irish research into developing their GM and blight free varieties. Second, how about toting up the costs to see how much protein production at home can be achieved? Is it dearer than the total environmental, human and transport costs of soya from Brazil or Argentina? Does the huge mark up by the major importer get counted? Are Scottish produced feed costs including lorry and ferry costs to transport winter feed any more expensive? Thirdly, if intensive pig and chicken production is too costly, why not extensify? Finally follow the example of the farmers who are restarting muck spreading, growing clover and planting triticale to fix nutrients ahead of other crops.

Alex Johnstone claimed that ‘at every stage in the development of modern agriculture there has been one group of another who have objected to progress’. Surely not the IAASTD? For it is the best guide for Scottish farmers who should also heed the Scottish Government’s pro-science precautionary policy that deems cultivating GM crops in Scotland is unacceptable and undesirable. Protecting a clean and natural environment to underpin a Scottish National Food Policy, this can’t be the sole property of producers. After all, the key question asked by the NFUS is ‘what’s on your plate’?

Rob Gibson MSP for Highlands and Islands

Monday, 8 September 2008

Gibson welcomes report's findings

News release

Immediate release


08/09/08


Rob Gibson SNP MSP for Highlands and Islands has welcomed the conclusions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh into the crisis in hills and Islands Agriculture.


Some of the key findings are that Scotland needs to:


● recognise that the continuing decline in hill and island agriculture has implications
for biodiversity, landscape management and food security


● develop a Strategic Land Use Policy Framework to provide a more integrated and
coordinated basis for decision-making


● substantial shifts in decision-making and delivery of public resources from
centrally-based agencies to regionally-based structures


● recognise the importance of tourism and stimulating economic growth and radically
reform the support structures for tourism


● halt the closure of rural post offices until a new, wider rationale is developed


● recognise that combating climate change now needs to be a major factor and that
the EU should be urged to give credit to forestry investment in meeting emissions
targets.


Commenting on the report entitled 'Committee of enquiry into the future of Scotland's hills and islands' he said,


"Many of the Society's recommendations underline the need for more powers over land use policy in Scotland. Investment as well as more hands-on local planning are both required. But undoubtedly the maintenance of crofts and family farms growing mixed crops and livestock are a key component. Clearly the small size of such farms retains more people. Also the Cap's Single Farm Payment scheme has paid producers who have failed to continue to produce. It must be reformed to support the needs of least favoured areas and small producers."

"Meanwhile the UK has powers to save post offices, arrange a favourable connection regime for renewable energy and taper fuel prices would all be required. These have not been applied, therefore the Royal Society report is only part of the solution. Independence and a much more devolved decision taking structure within Scotland will be the real saviour of our rural and island economy."


Note to editor:


Link to report
http://www.rse.org.uk/enquiries/hill_and_island_areas/index.htm

S3M-02516 Rob Gibson (Highlands and Islands) (Scottish National Party): Real Garlicky Win

That the Parliament congratulates the Really Garlicky Company in Nairn for its Best Farm Entrepreneur win at the Country Living and Waitrose Made in Britain Food Awards and recognises that during Scottish Food Fortnight local companies throughout the nation, and especially in the Highlands and Islands, are key to delivering good quality tasty food and will play a key factor in the development of the Scottish national food policy.

Supported by: Jamie Hepburn

Lodged on Monday, September 08, 2008; Current

S3M-02511 Rob Gibson (Highlands and Islands) (Scottish National Party): BBC Alba - Speed Up Freeview Option

That the Parliament welcomes the launch of the BBC Alba Gaelic television channel; wishes that all those involved will make the service a success; notes the potential that it has to boost the profile of the Gaelic language while informing and entertaining people throughout the country; however also notes, with disappointment, the fact that this service is not intended to be available through Freeview until after the digital switchover and that this will be subject to a review by the BBC Trust, and calls on the UK Government and BBC to speed up this process so that the channel has the chance to be watched by Gaels and non-Gaels throughout the nation who possess a Freeview box but do not have cable nor a satellite television.


Supported by: Jamie HepburnLodged on Monday, September 08, 2008; Current

Friday, 5 September 2008

Save the Titians

Letter published in the Herald

Saturday, 30 August 2008

Sir,



The National Galleries have revealed the urgent need to pay £100 million for the star pieces in the Bridgewater Collection in return for a continued loan of the other 25 paintings for another 21 years. All this haste is due, we are told, to the ultra-rich 7th Duke of Sutherland reassessing his family assets in view of current auction room prices for Old Masters. This raises several thoughts and serious questions for our public galleries and the ordinary tax payer.

Photo: Rob below the Duke of Sutherland's statue on Ben Bhraggie

Tracy Emin has called for a UK-wide subscription at a pound a skull which has eerie echoes from the time of the First Duke. She may not know that the late aristocrat's 'man of business' James Loch raised three monuments to the late Duke following a call for subscriptions in 1833. Many gentlemen of Sutherland gave generously and every tenant, left after the Duke's clearances, gave dutifully, thankful, no doubt, that they had been spared the evictions which were wrought by Loch and Sellar in the previous two decades. All the names were printed in a memorial for the gratifying estimation in which the First Duke was held by the gentlemen and inhabitants of Sutherland. The Herald is correct in saying that the infamous statue on Ben Bhraggie was erected in 1837, but having seen the correspondence in the National Library I can assure your readers that it was not completed till the end of 1838.

Nevertheless the Bridgewater Collection existed long before the 2nd Marquis of Stafford was rewarded with his dukedom. However since then death duties have complicated the inheritance processes of the rich. So loans to galleries and reassessments of asset values have to be done. I'm not against public subscriptions for such major works of art. Indeed the Scottish Government rightly indicated it will support the collection. Surely an appeal to the ultra-rich should be the first port of call, not from the pennies of the poor? However a couple of other matters need to be aired.

First, it was hinted by the John Leighton, director general of the NGS that 'we have known for decades that a moment like this would arrive'. The public should be told how many more works of art in the national collection are on loan, what their current market values amount to and whether the owners are likely to repossess their works as a result of their revalued family assets that could be threatened by death duties and burden the nation with more appeals for large sums.

Second, isn't this one of the very obvious ways that a National Oil Fund for Future Generations could have been invested? Unlike Norway which has amassed 200 billions in 12 years, we in Scotland have no such cushion for unexpected national costs and events.

Third, had the Sutherland family not fallen out and split their assets a hundred years ago, perhaps the 90,000 acres of Sutherland still held by the other branch of the family, under the ancient Scottish Earldom, could have been donated for national use and local development of the communities it still constrains. That would have kept the jewels of the art world and removed another bastion of private landed interests from our unfree land.

Yours
Rob Gibson MSP
4 Grant St., Wick
Caithness


Thursday, 4 September 2008

SCOTTISH GOVERNMENT'S PROGRAMME DEBATE

Speech from Rob Gibson SNP MSP on the Scottish Government's Programme

3 September 2008

I am delighted to welcome the Government's programme. I will first concentrate on the wealthier and fairer aspect. There has been talk about helping disadvantaged communities and the need for social justice. I cannot think of a more immediate way to achieve those goals than by abolishing the council tax.

Johann Lamont: Will the member give way?

Rob Gibson: Not at the moment, thank you. I will develop my argument first.


The people in my part of Scotland who have higher fuel bills, transport costs and food costs and lower incomes will welcome the abolition of the council tax even more than those in many other parts of the country. On the doorsteps during the election a year ago, that issue was first on their minds. In all the opinion polling since then, a majority of those who say that they will support each of the parties in Scotland support a local income tax and want an end to the council tax. That will be achieved in this year by the Government, which I welcome very much.

Johann Lamont: Will the member give way?

Rob Gibson: No, thank you—not just now. We must get away from the kindergarten attacks about property versus income. Eventually, we will have a chance to discuss the issue in more detail, but I cannot think of a better way of dealing with the unfair council tax and its increases than the freeze that started this year and its abolition in due course. We may have to revisit the issue in future if we give local government more powers.

I move on to two issues with which I am particularly involved in the Parliament and which are to do with the greener aspect as well as the wealthier and fairer one. I am delighted that we will have a climate change bill and a marine bill. The linkage between the two is important in the area in which I live. The First Minister, in describing the conflicts on the sea, said that the "demands on Scotland's marine and coastal environment" affect "the energy sector, shipping, fisheries, tourism and conservation."

We must find ways in which to accommodate each of those issues. I echo the points that have been made that the forthcoming climate change bill must be as effective as possible, but I believe that the Parliament will find a means to achieve that. In the committee system, we will reach a consensus and find practical ways to measure and make progress.

I will give a little example to show how we will resolve problems through the proposed marine bill. At present, in trying to give effect to the EU birds directive, the Government has asked Scottish Natural Heritage to consider extensions to some of the special protection areas. It is proposed that one such area in the Pentland Firth, covering Duncansby, Dunnet Head and Stroma, should include the coastal waters 2km offshore into the inner sound. The proposal has been criticised locally because of its potential to interfere with the development of tidal power schemes. The proposed marine bill has the capacity to deal with those conflicts. Indeed the Government will consider the extension of such special protection areas to make sure that the environment, birds—in the case of the Pentland Firth—and tidal power development can be accommodated. That is entirely possible given our geography.

As we become more capable in the Parliament and the country of being at ease with the environment and development—economic development is at the centre of the Government's programme—we see in the proposed climate change bill the ability to take a front-facing role on global action. We and our neighbours have a great opportunity to contribute to the wider European picture. I suggest to the chamber that through non-legislative measures, such as the extension of renewable energy production in our country, we can contribute to meeting not only our own electricity needs but those of our neighbours in the south—England, Wales and Ireland—and in Europe.

The energy resources of the far north, which I represent, could deliver cheaper electricity for us in the long term if investment in renewables is seen as a national priority. Guess which Government values the energy potential of the Pentland Firth? It is certainly not the UK Government. A fortnight ago, it stamped down hard yet again on allowing favourable grid-connection charges so that electricity generated here can be sent to market. Someone has to tackle the Office of Gas and Electricity Markets; clearly, the British Government is not doing so.

Last year, Malcolm Wicks, the UK energy minister, and David Cairns, assured the Caithness renewables conference that they were right behind them in developing renewable energy. People have seen right through that. Significantly, Gordon Brown's Government warned off the Scottish Government from talking to Norway about a super grid. Surely that is an inhibitor of the development of clean energy in Scotland to enhance our opportunities to reduce climate change. It is a good, practical example of where Scotland needs to be in control, where we need to work with our neighbours and partners and why the Scottish Government has to be in charge of our energy development. That is possible through the Government's programme and I commend it to Parliament.

14:48


Tuesday, 2 September 2008

Gibson urges volunteers for children's panel


News release
Immediate release

02/09/08

SNP MSP Rob Gibson has urged adults in the Highlands and Islands to help improve the prospects for children who have been neglected or abused by getting involved in children's panels.


Mr Gibson was talking at the start of this year's campaign to recruit more children's panel members.


He said...


"The Children's Panel is an important institution in public life. It can make a real change on the lives for youngsters who have undergone a turbulent time in their lives.


"By listening to those that have been neglected, abused or have fallen foul of the law and ensuring support is in place early we can improve the future outlook for them, the locality and Scotland as a whole."


"Children's panels can help children realise their potential, however for them to continue there needs to be volunteers. No special qualifications are needed and people from all backgrounds will help deliver a balanced system to improve the life chances for young people in the region."

ENDS


Note to Editor:

Ways to apply to join the panel:
Call: 0845 601 2770
Text: Panel3 to 61611
Website:
www.infoscotland.com/childrenspanel

Monday, 1 September 2008

Scottish minority languages on the agenda at Festival of Politics

Published in Holyrood Magazine

Tuesday, 26 August 2008


Progress has been made to recognise minority languages in Scotland but more must be done at both the domestic and EU level, according to a panel at the Festival of Politics.


Speaking at the ‘Linguistic Diversity in Europe – Let’s Begin at Home’ event chaired by Rob Gibson MSP in the Scottish Parliament, specialists in the field engaged in a lively debate on the way forward for Scots and other minority languages within the European context.

Neasa Ni Chinneide, native Irish speaker and President of the European Bureau of Lesser Used Languages, an organisation partly funded by the European Commission that promotes and funds minority languages in Europe, described the shift in culture and attitudes towards language taking place across Europe. It used to be the case, she said, that minority languages were viewed as a threat to cohesion and any mention of them would make EU politicians ‘sweat’. However major advances have been made in recent years to recognise and promote lesser used languages, she told the festival. The move by the French Government, “the European state with the strongest leaning towards monolinguislism”, on 21 July to recognise regional languages in their constitution was a major step which demonstrates this shift, Ni Chinneide said.

A disparity between the way Scots and Gaelic are treated by the UK and Scottish Governments was highlighted by Billy Kay, broadcaster and author of The Mither Tongue. Kay told the audience that although Scotland is home to 1.5 million Scots speakers compared with 60,000 Gaelic speakers, Gaelic has a highly effective lobby and gains more recognition and representation than the more widely spoken language with a Gaelic television channel due to be launched next month. He lamented the way Scots had often not been taken seriously by the political establishment in the past, recalling a former Scottish Culture Minister telling him he had thrown his invitation written in Scots in the bin, referring to it as ‘funny writing’. Kay commented: “I would say the UK is probably the second most hostile country in Europe to its minority languages.”

Mathew Fitt, author of Butt n Ben A Go Go and Education Officer with Itchy-Coo, an imprint for children’s books in Scots, spoke about the use of Scots in education. He said that a lot of progress was being made on this front under the SNP Government with Scots included in Curriculum for Excellence following a campaign. Fitt, who has visited around 500 schools across Scotland to promote the use of Scots in education, told the festival that in his experience when children are asked to speak in Scots in the classroom, the language they often use in the home, they fill with confidence. Fitt said: “Scots has often been ignored in the past and airbrushed out. This is changing but it must change faster.”

Ni Chinneide agreed that education was a key battleground for the promotion of minority languages, at all levels from primary to third level. The other chief battleground, she said, is media. New media, including internet and digital television channels, present a major opportunity for languages to break into the mainstream she added.

Neil Mitchison, the European Commission Representative in Scotland, stressed that the debate on Scotland’s minority languages must begin at home. Political decisions must be taken in Scotland first and then the EU can play a role, acting as an umpire in the process, he said.

Sunday, 31 August 2008

Gibson corrects 'geographically challenged' Peacock

News release
Immediate release

31/08/08

SNP MSP has called Peter Peacock 'geographically challenged' after the Labour MSP claimed that there was no Highlands and Islands representation on the Scottish Governments Food and Drink Leadership Forum.

Mr Gibson pointed out that one of the members, Ken Mackenzie, was born, schooled and lives in the Highlands.

Mr Mackenzie grew up in Drumnadrochit, studied at Inverness Royal Academy, and lives in Inverness. He was heavily involved in the year of Highland Culture as well as communities throughout the region in his capacity as Chief Officer for the Scottish Co-op.

MR Gibson said...

"Last time I checked Inverness was still the capital of the Highlands and Drumnadrochit hadn't magically moved to a greenfeild site outside Barcelona. That seems to suggest to me that some one hailing from Drumnadrochit and living in Inverness is indeed a Highlander. So the claim that there is no Highland Representation on the forum is wrong, unless Peter Peacock and the Labour Party knows something about geography that I don't."

"I find it fairly amusing and mildly worrying that a former convener of Highland Council and Education Minister could be that geographically challenged! I know that Scottish Labour are looking to go in a new direction, I only hope (for their sake) that Peter Peacocks isn't their navigator! Or they might find themselves up the strath without a paddle!"

"Are Labour prepared to support the working groups from throughout Scotland that will help build the first National Food Policy Scotland has had?"

ENDS

Friday, 29 August 2008

Lesser used languages may be key to self-esteem

Published in the John O'Groat Journal

Friday, 29 August 2008


MATTHEW Fitt, author of Butt and Ben A Go-Go, science fiction in broad Scots, was one of the panellists in my Festival of Politics slot last Friday.

We were joined in a packed Committee Room 3 in the Parliament by Neasa Ní Chinnéide, president of the European Bureau for Lesser Used Languages, Billy Kay, broadcaster and author of The Mither Tongue and Neil Mitchison from the European Commission. We discussed the prospects for minority languages in our own country in the context of the European Year of Intercultural Dialogue.


From the floor we heard from Swiss, German and Finnish audience members as well as several Scots who want to see Gaelic and Scots well-supported and given equal status alongside English, where appropriate in our multilingual nation.


A teacher of English asked the panel if Scots is really a language. She said she found no difficulty in teaching Burns poems and the like in her English lessons. The reply was that there are richer and weaker dialects of Scots from Shetland, Orkney through Caithness, Moray and all the way through Scotland to Ulster; however the panellists showed that Scots derives from an older strand of English than modern English and has developed separately. Despite persecution as slang it has a literature of over 600 years and, while weakened by monolingual school teaching, the Doric or Lallans or broad Scots survives as the daily speech of around one and a half million of us today.


Matthew Fitt is also a co-author of many publications for kids by Itchy Coo Books. He has been encouraging school children in over 500 classrooms across Scotland to have fun getting their mouths round the guid Scots tongue. This week he is in Thurso and Wick.

Most countries in Europe speak several languages daily and often look after them better than Britain has done. So Matthew's school visit in Caithness should be unremarkable. But this is Scotland where speaking anything other than correct English in school has long overshadowed young lives. Speaking Scots in Caithness classrooms comes at an interesting juncture. The controversy among some as to the role of Gaelic in the county begs some related questions. Should the richness of Caithness dialect have equal status in spoken and written forms with English?


In my view a Gaelic proverb helps us answer this. It says "Tìr gun chànain, Tìr gun anam", namely "a land without a language is a land without a soul". So when Scottish people were or are denied the right to speak their preferred tongue, be it Scots, English, Gaelic, Urdu or whatever, it is no way to bolster their self-esteem. I look forward to reactions to Matthew's impact on Caithness school children and their parents, for self-esteem is a key ingredient in a confident society.

Energy resources here in the Far North could deliver us cheaper electricity in the long term, if investment in renewables is seen as a national priority. Guess which government values the energy potential of the Pentland Firth? Certainly not the UK Government. Last week they stamped down hard on tidal and other renewable projects in the North and on our islands by refusing to allow lower grid connection charges than the punitive rates set by OFGEM.

Last year Malcolm Wicks, the UK energy minister, assured the Caithness Regeneration Conference of his support for future clean-power plans. David Cairns from the Scotland Office in Whitehall said the same. Now we know they don't really go the distance. Now we know that Scotland needs to forge ahead and make partnerships with our North Sea neighbours to build a super grid, which incidentally Gordon Brown's Government also disapproves of when they criticised direct contacts being made with the Norwegian Government by Jim Mather, our energy minister in Alex Salmond's team.


The lesson is straightforward, energy security in Scotland will have to be organised by Scots with our neighbours on agreed terms. These neighbours should include England, Wales and Ireland, so we need to demand an equal say for the Scottish Government with the others involved. Anything less will leave us at the mercy of London ministers with other ideas.


Hard-hit electricity and gas customers know full well that while we pay through the nose, shareholders enjoy huge profits made by supply companies. Investing for the future does not mean going to the ends of the earth. We want investment right here. A couple of weeks back EDF, Electricity de France, a nationalised company, was about to take over British Energy but did not like the asking price.

Meanwhile Norway and other energy rich countries have not allowed their residents to suffer as we do here. Norway's national oil company Statoil oversees a whole range of energy developments, on and offshore, and works in partnership with the oil majors. That national interest has been lacking in free-market Britain and now we reap the whirlwind. We have to demand much more than windfall profits to cushion oil and gas price hikes. As politicians and public down south get in a lather, our needs in the colder north are even more urgent. That's why the Scottish Government needs full control over energy development so that price reductions can become a reality and investment gives us real energy security.

Meanwhile a YouGov poll in Scotland showing that 74 per cent agreed that the UK Government should introduce a windfall tax on the energy companies was mirrored across the UK.

About 700,000 Scottish households are already living in fuel poverty and Energywatch are warning that the latest price rise could increase that figure to 1,000,000 by the end of 2008. The SNP has constantly called on the London Government to bring forward measures to boost the economy and protect people facing fuel poverty. Will Gordon Brown take decisive action to help? Your guess is as good as mine.

RG

Games act review announced

News release/Environment Release
Immediate release

29/08/08

Highlands and Islands SNP MSP Rob Gibson has welcomed a response from the Scottish Government that it will start a review of the Games Act before the end of the year.


The response came from Environment Minister Michael Russell in a Parliamentary question on the subject from Rob Gibson.


The Minister stated that the Government intends to carry out a review into the Act before the end of the year.

Mr Gibson, who challenged the Scottish Executive to carry out a similar review 4 years ago when the EU prosecuted the UK for failing to sufficiently protect: black grouse, ptarmigan, red grouse and partridge, said…..

"I welcome the Scottish Government's pro-active response. The intention to review the Game Acts before the year's end is good news. It will allow stakeholders to have their say before changes are proposed."

"For my part the longstanding anomalies of grouse, black grouse and ptarmigan being both game birds and environmentally endangered species has always been a puzzle. I hope that common sense can prevail and that a new regime of protection for all wild birds will result."

"The Scottish Executive did not agree to a review when asked in the past. The new attitude shown by the SNP Government is most welcome and shows it values both sustainable economic development in rural areas and protection of endangered species."

ENDS

Note


Copy of Q & A regarding gaming laws.

SCOTTISH PARLIAMENT WRITTEN ANSWER@

29 August 2008
Index Heading: Rural Affairs and the Environment - Rob Gibson (Highlands and Islands) (SNP): To ask the Scottish Executive whether it intends to conduct a review of the Game Acts and, if so, when the review will commence, what its timescale will be and what opportunities will be available for stakeholders to make a contribution.
(S3W-15510)


Mr Michael Russell:


The Scottish Government does intend to conduct a review of the Game Acts, which will commence before the end of the year. Early tasks will be to assess the scope of work required and to set a realistic timeframe. Part of the process will be a public consultation, providing stakeholders the opportunity to contribute.

SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE